Last Updated on December 17, 2025

For a lot of people, the hardest part of changing their drinking isn’t the drinks themselves. It’s the cognitive distortions that happen after drinking.

The replay. The second-guessing. The way one night can suddenly feel like proof of something much bigger. If that sounds familiar, it’s not because you’re bad at moderation or lacking discipline. It’s because your brain is doing what brains tend to do when something matters.

Psychology has a name for these mental habits: cognitive distortions. They’re common, automatic thinking patterns that show up under stress, guilt, or uncertainty. And when they go on unrecognized, they can quietly make mindful drinking feel heavier than it needs to be.

Here are ten distortions that often show up when people are trying to change their relationship with alcohol, and how they can interfere with progress without you realizing it.

Watch The Related Podcast

1. All-or-nothing Thinking

This is the mindset that turns everything into a pass/fail test. And it’s not possible to pass every time! We’ve said it before, and we’ll say it again: Progress is not linear.

You had more than you planned, so the entire effort gets written off. The weeks of drinking less, paying attention, or recovering faster somehow stop counting. One imperfect night becomes a reason to “start over.”

The problem with all-or-nothing thinking is that behavior change doesn’t work that way. Most progress lives in the middle, where things are better than before but not flawless.

2. Overgeneralizing

Overgeneralizing takes one moment and stretches it into a story about who you are.

When you overgeneralize, “I drank more than I wanted last night” can quickly become “I always do this” or “Nothing has really changed.” The brain skips over the rest of the data—for instance, the times you have succeeded in sticking to your goals—and lands on a familiar, discouraging conclusion. It can feel convincing in the moment, but it’s rarely actually accurate.

3. Mental Filtering

This distortion decides what gets remembered. You might have stayed aligned with your intentions most of the week, but one night takes over the emotional memory. Progress fades into the background, while the slip-up plays on repeat. Nothing about the progress disappeared. It just didn’t get the spotlight.

4. Discounting the Positive

Discounting the positive sounds subtle, but it’s powerful.

“Yes, I drank less, but it was an easy week.”
“Yes, I stuck to my plan, but that doesn’t really count.”

When improvement is constantly minimized, motivation tends to drop. Not because change isn’t happening, but because you never let yourself feel it.

5. Jumping to Conclusions

This is where assumptions sneak in without evidence.

Maybe you assume other people noticed how much you drank. Or that they’re judging you because you’ve talked about cutting back. Or that you already know how future nights will go.

These thoughts arrive fully formed, dressed up as certainty, even though they’re guesses. The brain fills in blanks quickly—especially when alcohol and identity are involved.

6. Magnification

Magnification takes a manageable moment and blows it up.

Instead of “That didn’t go how I hoped,” the story becomes “This is a real problem” or “This means I’m headed backward.” The mind jumps ahead before you’ve had time to observe what actually happened. Zooming out often tells a much calmer story than zooming in.

7. Emotional Reasoning

Emotional reasoning follows a simple formula: “I feel it, so it must be true.” Feeling guilty becomes proof that you did something wrong. Feeling out of control becomes proof that you are out of control. Try to catch this when it happens, and remember what information feelings actually convey. Feelings matter, and they can be useful signals, but they’re not objective evidence.

8. “Should” Statements

“I should be further along by now.”
“I shouldn’t need this much effort.”

These thoughts might sound motivating at first glance, but all they really do is put the pressure on. They don’t tell you what to do next. They only (falsely) signal that you’re “behind” in some way.

Remember: Change doesn’t move on a schedule. “Should” thinking tends to ignore that.

9. Labeling

Labeling turns behavior into identity.

Instead of noticing what happened, the mind jumps straight to character judgments: “I’m weak,” “I’m undisciplined,” “I can’t trust myself.” A single moment gets promoted into a definition.

Behavior is something you do. Identity is something much bigger than that.

10. Personalization and Blame

This distortion can show up in two opposite ways. Either everything becomes your fault (“I ruined the night”), or nothing does (“That’s just what happens when I drink”). One leads to shame. The other blocks reflection. And what do they have in common? Neither leaves much room for learning.

Why Noticing These Patterns Actually Helps

Cognitive distortions tend to show up when you care. They’re not a huge reason for alarm. Instead, think of them as a sign that your brain is adjusting to something new.

The goal isn’t to argue with your thoughts or replace them with perfect ones. Often, the most useful shift is simply recognizing what’s happening.

“This is all-or-nothing thinking.”
“This is me magnifying one moment.”

That small bit of distance can change how quickly you recover, how harshly you judge yourself, and how much weight you give to a single night.

Want to change your perspective? Begin your mindful drinking journey with a 15-day free trial of Sunnyside.

More about Sunnyside and Naltrexone

Sunnyside is a holistic program to help you build a healthier relationship with alcohol, using a proven, science-backed method. Whether you want to become a more mindful drinker, drink less, or eventually quit drinking, Sunnyside can help you reach your goals. We take a positive, friendly approach to habit change, so you never feel judged or pressured to quit.

When you join Sunnyside, you’ll start by completing a 3-minute private assessment so we can learn a bit about you. Once that’s done, you’ll get a 15-day free trial to test out everything, including our daily habit change tools, tracking and analytics, community and coaching, and education and resources. It’s a full package designed specifically to adapt to your goals and help you reach them gradually, so you can make a huge impact on your health and well-being.

In addition, Sunnyside Med now offers access to compounded naltrexone, a prescription medication that can reduce cravings and binge drinking, giving you the peace of mind to make long-term change.

Get your 15-day free trial of Sunnyside today, and start living your healthiest life.